ArcRoster logo
BookSirens alternative

BookSirens finds readers. ArcRoster keeps them.

BookSirens is one of the most cost-effective ways to get an ARC in front of new readers. What it isn't built for is the list you grow afterwards - the readers you invite yourself, launch after launch. That's the part ArcRoster runs.

ArcRosterBookSirens
Core modelYour own reviewer roster + accountabilityReader marketplace + ARC delivery
Finds new readers for youNo - public sign-up page you shareYes - its reader community requests your book
Reviewer reliability scoreYes - per reader, across every launchSite-wide average (~75%) published, no score you keep
Reviewer history you ownPermanent CRM with tags, notes, CSV exportReaders are found per campaign through its pool
Book acceptanceNo acceptance review (content terms apply)Books must pass BookSirens' review
Pricing shapeFree plan; $7–39/mo, no per-reader fees$10 setup + $2 per downloading reader, or $100/year for 2 pen names

Compiled October 2026 from BookSirens's public pricing and documentation. Features and prices change - verify current details on their site before deciding.

Head to head: Booksprout vs BookSirens · NetGalley vs BookSirens

Where ArcRoster wins

Your list compounds

On BookSirens each campaign starts from its reader pool. In ArcRoster every reader you approve stays in a CRM you own, with their full history, so your second and third launches start from proven readers instead of from zero.

You know who to invite first

BookSirens publishes a site-wide average of about 75% of downloading readers posting a review, and says individual books range from above 90% to below 50%. ArcRoster tells you the rate for each of your readers, so you can invite your reliable readers first and stop sending copies to people who never review.

No per-reader bill

Readers you invite yourself through ArcRoster cost nothing extra. Plans are flat - Free, then $7, $17, or $39 a month - however many of your readers download.

Where BookSirens wins

New readers on demand

If you have no list yet, BookSirens' reader community is real discovery that ArcRoster doesn't provide. Its pay-as-you-go plan only bills for readers who actually download, and you can cap spend with a reader limit.

Strong published review rate

BookSirens' own published average is around 75%, and in one documented cross-platform romantasy launch it delivered 93% from invited readers and 72% from organic ones - among the best results in that campaign.

Questions

BookSirens vs ArcRoster, answered.

What is a good alternative to BookSirens?
For finding new ARC readers, the closest alternatives are Hidden Gems (curated reader teams, priced per reader), Booksprout (a monthly subscription with a shared reader pool), and NetGalley (trade readers, much more expensive). For managing the readers you already have - tracking who downloads and reviews, sending reminders, and scoring reliability across launches - ArcRoster is the alternative, and it has a free plan.
How much does BookSirens cost?
As of October 2026, BookSirens' Promote plan is a $10 setup fee per book plus $2 for each reader who downloads it, with the promotion running for three months. Its Author plan is $100 a year for unlimited ARCs across two pen names with no per-reader fees. Readers you invite yourself are not billed. Check booksirens.com/pricing for current rates.
Can I use BookSirens and ArcRoster together?
Yes, and that's how most authors would use them: BookSirens to reach new readers for a launch, and ArcRoster to run your own ARC team. Readers you meet through BookSirens can join your team through your ArcRoster sign-up page, and from then on their review history builds with you instead of with a platform.
Does ArcRoster have a reader pool like BookSirens?
No. ArcRoster doesn't sell access to readers. It gives each pen name a public sign-up page where readers apply and you approve them, then tracks every campaign you send them and scores each reader on whether they review on time.
Your next launch, reviewed

Build a roster that outlasts any one launch.

ArcRoster is in public beta, and there's a free plan to start on. Bring your reviewers, run your next campaign, and see who actually shows up.